EAS Today

EditorialEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS UpdatesEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageJörg Hillebrand @ MastodonEAS @ Facebook

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
21 Oct 2024

Adiós Cerritos

When a still unnamed new animated Trek series was announced in October 2018, I was cautiously optimistic. I could imagine that the Star Trek Universe was big enough for an animated comedy. Well, the first Lower Decks trailer from July 2020 with its focus on swearing, farts, slime, zombies and similarly lame jokes temporarily discouraged me. Still, I was never really concerned that the show could damage the continuity or harm the franchise in any way. This is in part because I underestimated Lower Decks and didn't expect it to be more than a side show, a light-hearted companion to live-action Trek. I never imagined how relevant it would become for the franchise and the fandom and how well it would stack up against the live-action series (irrespective of its canon status).

Lower Decks embraces the traditional optimism of Star Trek like no other recent series in my book. It is free from dystopian aspects as they pervade the settings, the characters and the stories of the modern live-action shows. And as much as Lower Decks loves to comment on the downsides, especially concerning the underappreciation of low-ranking personnel, the series successfully establishes Starfleet as a family. Tendi, Rutherford, Boimler and Mariner may have their disagreements, but they are in it together, and so is the bridge crew - largely without narcissistic solo efforts or hidden agendas. The feeling of camaraderie is as strong here as it hasn't been since 2005.

Character arcs are the spice of modern series of any genre, and the ones of Lower Decks are more consequentially developed and stronger in some regards than those in live-action Trek. Take Mariner's survivor guilt (as revealed in "The Inner Fight") or Rutherford's gloomy back story (that finally comes to light in "Reflections"), which for me work better than Burnham's or Tilly's developments in Discovery. And even though their faces consist of just a few lines, Boimler and Tendi feel almost as real as Stamets or Saru (no offense meant).

I have probably mentioned it in many of my reviews, but I wish to reemphasize how faithfully Lower Decks recreates the world of the 24th century (in-universe) and of the Golden Age of 90's Trek (in real life). Starships, sets and props are reproduced or newly created with loving attention to established details, although everything would be possible. In many ways, this animated series is more authentic than multi-million dollar productions that strive to "update" Star Trek to something more bombastic and sometimes hardly recognizable on the visual side.

In light of its authenticity and of its countless in-jokes it is almost ironical that Lower Decks is the one among the recent Star Trek series that explores the most strange new worlds and overall relies the least on nostalgia.

Lower Decks does have its share of stories or lines of dialogue that are seen by some as mockery of Star Trek, but I think it is in line with how fans have been talking all along. Lower Decks is made by fans (the creators leave no doubt about that), it is made for fans (casual viewers don't get half of the jokes), and it is about fans on a meta level (because Mariner, Boimler, Tendi and Rutherford are into everything Starfleet). It has its heart in the right place. Thank you very much to Mike McMahan and his team for bringing us this show!

Much of my above praise applies to Prodigy likewise, but Lower Decks has a special place in my heart - because of the characters and the kind of humor that has grown on me. I admit it took a while. Also, Lower Decks helped me through a difficult time in my life when I was recovering from a serious injury and didn't know whether I would be able to return to a normal life again.

Season 5 of Lower Decks will be the last one. I can't imagine this of all series was canceled due to low ratings, to negative feedback or to a lack of story ideas. Maybe we just have to accept that nothing is supposed to last longer than that in an ever-changing media landscape. Still, I am sad to see Lower Decks of all series go. Although I can keep telling myself that Strange New Worlds isn't bad, that Starfleet Academy will not suck and that Section 31 perhaps just isn't for me, I will miss the endearing crew of the Cerritos and I will miss the authentic Trek feel and spirit of the show.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
  • 15 Mar 2025

    I don't take Miral's statement as definitive proof that the setting was unreal; I tend to believe the opposite, in fact. (The novels, though non-canon, have Miral also having experienced these events, while on a vision-quest on Boreth). I quite enjoyed Barge of the Dead, for its Klingon mythology story, the treatment of religion in a skeptics' world (how her crewmates automatically default to treating what she vitally believes as important for her mother's eternal soul as unimportant because they don't believe in its reality, and the struggle to convince them), and for B'elanna's character... particularly the moment where she is holding everyone at bay with the Bat'leth, demanding to know what all of them want from her; it resonates strongly, and feels like a very powerful moment for her character (any symbolizing who she has long been, holding the whole world at bay).

  • 10 Mar 2025

    Added: Anomalous class names, Reused class names, Commemorative registries

  • 09 Mar 2025

    Added the Equinox (Nova class).

  • 07 Mar 2025
    2024 Earth has become the Confederation

    would that not be 2399?

  • 02 Mar 2025

    An interesting design that would deserve to be fleshed out - although or because it would need a backstory to make sense. Not among the favorite Federation ships simply because it is pre-Federation. ;-)

  • 01 Mar 2025

    I don't know if it's said often enough, but thank you for all of your hard work in creating and maintaining all of this!

  • 01 Mar 2025

    Still there but only on the episode index pages, like https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/pro.htm --> https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/episodes/episode-table.php?series=PRO .

  • 28 Feb 2025

    Where is the catalogue of every review where you can quick reference or sort them based on different criteria? Or was that discontinued?

  • 27 Feb 2025

    What are your thoughts on this one?
    https://youtu.be/MO_tGuNt7x4?si=iGZMo5-w3Q6U8ZE6

  • 26 Feb 2025

    "There is yet another problem with the back story. The Equinox must have run into the Ankari at the beginning of the journey, still close to the Caretaker, because the ship couldn't have come far without the help of the creatures they were introduced to by the Ankari. Although the Ankari may possess an extremely advanced warp drive (which is not powered by dead creatures), it is a stretch that they would be encountered just 50 light-years from Voyager's position, some 30,000 light-years from where the Equinox first ran into them. Also, wouldn't it have been worth a try to acquire their propulsion technology?"

    I took this differently; that the Ankari encounter was relatively recently. The Equinox had been limping along after traveling for (6ish) years, chain of command long-since broke down, the crew became close. Finally, on the verge of collapse, they find the Ankari- and make up a significant amount of ground in the last few weeks/months. Thus, the Ankari don't have a great propulsion technology, and aren't back by the Caretaker. They are farther back than is reasonable for them to be 50 light-years away (but, they could be like the Hirogen, simply wide-spread travelers; heck, the Talaxians don't have super-engines, but they will be encountered more-distant yet!), but this is still somethinng like an 80/20 split- only the last, perhaps, fifth of this journey has been performed with the creatures.

    They are farther along, but they are 'so close' as in 'so close to a solution,' rather than 'so close to Earth.' As in, 'we're on the verge of making this work sustainably.'

    Now, does this solve all the problems the review brings up? No. But it does alter the parameters a bit.

  • 15 Mar 2025
    Two more Voyager retro reviews, of Seven's encounter with her past in "Survival Instinct" and B'Elanna's journey to Klingon hell in "Barge of the Dead".
  • 09 Mar 2025
    I have added considerations on the USS Equinox to the article on Starship Size Issues.
  • 08 Mar 2025
    Complete redesign of the Journal of Applied Treknology. Although there have been hardly any updates in recent years, the bad colors and tiny font sizes as well as the ghastly code (thank you, Frontpage!) annoyed me so much that I spent several days to recode it. Please tell me if there are display problems with certain browsers or devices. While I was at it, I also added six new designs.
  • 02 Mar 2025
    I have updated the Links and added a new link for each one I had to remove. Do good and visit another Trek site today!
  • 01 Mar 2025
    The Episode Master List now allows to create different forms of diagrams (bar chart, histogram) with filtered or sorted episode data. Let me know if there are any problems with any browser.
  • 25 Feb 2025
    Here are two more Voyager retro reviews, of "Warhead" with Harry and the stubborn bomb and of the exciting multilayered conflicts in "Equinox I/II".
  • 22 Feb 2025
    Find numerous additions and improvements in Jörg's article on Observations in TNG: "First Contact".
  • 16 Feb 2025
    Two more TNG season 1 observation articles have been upgraded: Observations in TNG: "Coming of Age" and Observations in TNG: "Heart of Glory".
  • 15 Feb 2025
    I have uploaded about 100 high-resolution photos of studio miniatures to the Starship Gallery, such as of several Federation shuttles, of Deep Space 9 or of the USS Yamaguchi. Please follow the "updated" signs to see all updates.
  • 09 Feb 2025
    Jörg identifies the Paintings and Photos in Picard's Study in PIC season 1 in a new article.
  • 02 Feb 2025
    I have improved two more of Jörg's oldest TNG observation articles with more references and better pictures: Observations in TNG: "Home Soil" and Observations in TNG: "When the Bough Breaks".
  • 01 Feb 2025
    Just a quick note that I have added the ships and other facts from "Section 31" to various pages of the site.
  • 27 Jan 2025
    Final update to the EAS Fleet Yards: high-resolution orthos of Asia class, Eclipse class and Asia refit.
  • 25 Jan 2025
    Here is my full-spoiler review of "Section 31" with Michelle Yeoh. The comments are open, as are the guest reviews. Please share your opinion on the streaming movie. Anyone who thinks it doesn't suck?
  • 17 Jan 2025
    Here is a new list: All Star Trek Movies Ranked. Feel free to post your personal order in the comments.
  • 10 Jan 2025
    I have added more columns to the Episode Master List, such as "Air date" and "Episode ID", which allow to sort the episodes and movies in still different ways.
Jörg Hillebrand @ Mastodon
  • 17 Mar 2025

    The Defense sub-systems station display in 's "Trials and Tribble-ations"↗️↘️ is based on a display often seen in season 1 of , like here in "The Menagerie I"↙️. "Relics"↖️ also featured a similar Defense Sub-systems display.

  • 17 Mar 2025

    The engineering MSD was modified between seasons 3 ("Booby Trap"⬇️) and 4 ("Galaxy's Child"⬆️) of . The display received new stronger light sources, the isolinear chip banks are no longer green but blue now and there's a new lareg red label on the bottom left.

  • 17 Mar 2025

    The buttonless Defense sub-systems station to the right of the main viewscreen is only seen in a few season 1+2 episodes, like "The Corbomite Maneuver"↖️, "Mudd's Women"⬆️, "The Menagerie II"↗️ and "The Doomsday Machine"↙️. It finally gets buttons in "Trials and Tribble-ations"⬇️↘️.

  • 17 Mar 2025

    I love the moments on when Troi is seen sensing strong emotions before anyone else realizes what is going on, like here in "Sarek"↖️, "The Wounded"↗️, "Night Terrors"⬅️➡️ and "Silicon Avatar". My favourite is "Lessons"↘️, though, when she senses Picard falling in love and is happy for him!🤩

  • 16 Mar 2025

    Dr. Leah Brahms uses the turbolift close to the engineering "pool table" twice in 's "Galaxy's Child"↖️↗️. The Jefferies tube junction was moved here between seasons 5 and 6, as can be seen in these screenshots from "The Quality of Life"↘️ and "Lessons"↙️.

  • 16 Mar 2025

    Here's a comparison of the wall console to the right of the main viewscreen and the Defense Sub-Systems station, as seen in ' "The Doomsday Machine"⬆️ and 's "The Trouble with Tribbles"⬇️.

  • 16 Mar 2025

    's "The Best of Both Worlds I" features the standard left-handed type 2 Cobra phasers in almost all scenes in the episode, on Jouret IV and on the Borg cube, as can be seen in these screenshot. There are however some right-handed phaser appearances in this episode as well.

  • 16 Mar 2025

    For 's "Trials and Tribble-ations"⬇️, the two right-most bridge stations were recreated, namely the "Defense Sub-Systems" and "Defense and weapons" stations, here seen in ' "The Corbomite Maneuver"⬆️.

  • 15 Mar 2025

    Sometimes, the LCARS translights warped a little, like in this aft bridge station shot in 's "Galaxy's Child". Notice the slightly wonky Starfleet Operations - Sectors 21166 - 23079 display.

  • 15 Mar 2025

    Tasha Yar keeps changing back and forth between the regular type 2 Cobra phaser ⬅️ and the newly created props with the dark trapezoid mark on the handle ➡️ in 's "Yesterday's Enterprise".

EAS Timeline @ Facebook

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery