EAS Today

EditorialEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS UpdatesEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageJörg Hillebrand @ MastodonEAS @ Facebook

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
19 Jan 2025

Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance

The fandom appears more divided over Starfleet Academy than ever before. Many reject the series outright, criticizing the setting, characters, storytelling and the inevitable "wokeness". The number of naysayers seems even greater than those who opposed Discovery. Either that, or they have simply become more vocal and visible. On the other side, supporters celebrate Starfleet Academy as a fresh opportunity to explore new worlds and seek out new audiences. That's only fair, but some dismiss criticism outright. I also don't think that framing disappointed fans as being of one mind with evil Elon is helpful. In the media, the middle ground is drowned out by the extremes. The episodes themselves almost feel designed to provoke division by alienating long-time fans with broad humor and heavy-handed references. Yet even detractors admit the show looks better than expected. The lingering question is: Can Starfleet Academy become a sustainable Trek series, one that simply requires time for audiences to adjust to its style?

I don't consider myself a detractor, but rather a skeptic. However, it is difficult to escape the framing, and in my case, to set aside grievances in order to enjoy what SFA does well. My reviews of "Kids These Days" and "Beta Test" seem to lean heavily on weaknesses, but as an afterthought, I want to highlight the strengths. The sets are spectacular. Everything is bright, crisp and polished, much like in the Golden Age of the 1990s. Despite occasional lens flares and CGI excess, the cinematography is outstanding. SFA is the best-looking modern Trek show. The cast also impresses. Holly Hunter delivers as expected, but the young actors deserve praise for making the cadets feel alive and likable. Then there's the broader setting. Discovery laid the groundwork, but its constant galaxy-saving missions left little room to explore the 32nd century in depth. SFA already does far more in terms of worldbuilding.

I believe Starfleet Academy has the potential to evolve into a meaningful series in the best Trek tradition, if it can deliver compelling stories while cutting back on the silly jokes, awkward situations and nostalgia overload. That said, one more aspect currently doesn't quite work for me. With the exception of Caleb, every cadet is an alien, yet they all feel essentially human. They are distinguished by special abilities, rather than by different values and traditions. SAM has even been programmed as a 17-year-old awkward human girl. I would expect cultural clashes, but the aliens integrate more seamlessly than a German exchange student at an American college. Ironically Caleb is the outsider in terms of the cultural background.

I try to keep an open mind and resist the polarized framing that surrounds Starfleet Academy. Still, my reviews will probably remain in flux as my perspective is evolving. What I can say with confidence, however, is that the claims of SFA being a "disaster" or a "disgrace" are totally exaggerated. The show certainly has its flaws, but I can only encourage fellow skeptics to give Starfleet Academy a fair chance.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
  • 05 Apr 2026

    Thanks for the reference! Yes, I suppose that's an explanation. As a result of ENT, SNW, DIS, post-burn DIS, and SFA the Star Trek universe becomes a lot more like the Star Wars universe in the sense that there's hardly any technological progress over the course of a thousand years (or whatever) because ENT is essentially VOY except that they say "polarize our hull-plating" instead of "raise shields," SNW has a holodeck, and they don't effectively/consistently use any of the magic 32nd century tech they supposedly have because it would preclude danger/drama.

  • 05 Apr 2026

    This article is the reference for the assignment of series to different continuities: https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/inconsistencies/continuities.htm So "Discoverse" means it is the same universe but seen through a different lens. The problem you have with ENT is a consequence of the series showing some sort of quantum leap (<-- unintentional pun!). Before the launch of NX-01, technology was on "First Contact"-level and deep space was unexplored, after that technology was suddenly on TOS-level and space was open for exploration and colonization.

  • 04 Apr 2026

    I appreciate the way that you handle the difference between the prime universe of Star Trek and the Disco-verse and the Abrams-verse. (I have to admit that I don't think of the Abrams-verse movies as even being Star Trek in any sense, so I appreciate being reminded of your system for categorizing them. Like you, I never think of Very Short Treks or Scouts.) If I'm understanding your system correctly, it seems that while Discovery, Short Treks, Strange New Worlds, Section 31, and Starfleet Academy all exist in the Disco-verse, Picard, Lower Decks, and Prodigy are continuations of the prime universe. I think this distinction will probably prove reasonable when we actually get an original series set in the prime universe timeline at some point after these three series. Such a series will likely consider the destruction of Romulus canon as it sets up a new galacto-political situation. It's my hope that we will eventually have such a series with an all-new crew and all new ship without legacy characters (the way TNG charted Star Trek's new course back in the 1980s).

    This is totally beside the point, but I will add that I personally would also carve out an Archer-verse for Star Trek: Enterprise. This is not simply because the whole rest of Star Trek (TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY) had never heard of Archer's Enterprise (I remember clearly Commander Decker showing the V'Ger probe a gallery on the TMP recreation deck "all these vessels were called Enterprise," and a similar gallery of models in the conference room of the Enterprise-D, neither of which included the Akira-prise). But my complaints about the series are much more substantial as a historian. In order to have a Federation filled with human colonies that have populations in the millions like Deneva (1 million), Marcos XII (millions), Mantilles (82 million) by the TOS/TAS era, there needed to be dozens of large human colonies by the time of ENT. Assuming for a very high historical growth rate of 3%, to get to a population of millions by the time of TOS, Marcos XII will have needed an initial 10,000 colonists 155 years prior to "And the Children Shall Lead" (meaning the colony would already be some 40 years old by the time the Akira-prise is launched). Enterprise completely misunderstands this demographic reality, making human expansion as of the TOS era impossible. In addition, in order to have all of the lost Earth colonies that are found like Terratin, Mariposa, Bringloid V, Tau Cygna V, Moab IV, etc., Earth needs to have had "its aggressive colonizing period" as Spock describes it in TOS "The Balance of Terror," which would have occurred prior to when ENT is set. ENT is totally at odds with the demographic and historical necessity of the prime universe in shows that are canon.

    A canonical show in the timeframe of ENT should have been set on a ship that was not named Enterprise, that was substantially more primitive, which was dealing with the reality of human space that included hundreds of independent and semi-autonomous Earth colonies (even the Martian colonies) that need to come together even before humanity can gather a Federation that includes the Vulcans, Andorrans, Tellarites, and others. For these reasons and more, it's clear to me that ENT is not set in the prime universe (despite the efforts of Lower Decks and other recent series to canonize it), and should instead be considered a stand-alone Archer-verse adventure.

  • 04 Apr 2026

    Added hematology analyzer.

  • 01 Apr 2026

    Another great investigation. By all means keep them coming!

  • 31 Mar 2026

    This is pretty cool! Thanks for compiling your Ten Forward posts into a single article on this site!

  • 31 Mar 2026

    https://www.instagram.com/p/DTy0iy2Dzi_/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ==

    Torothan shuttle

  • 31 Mar 2026

    I would love to know these things, too. My hope is that somebody who worked on the production will read this and give us some additional background info. :-)

  • 31 Mar 2026

    Thank you very much! :-)

  • 31 Mar 2026

    You're very welcome! :-)

EAS Favourites @ Deviantart
  • 14 Nov 2025

    This is my re-done version of an old, old MSD I did back in 2009 ish. I updated it to my latest quality level.

    I had this up before, but missed it when I had to completely re-upload my gallery due to DA allowing all and sundry to download the hi res copies for free!

    thumbnail
  • 23 Oct 2025

    An efficient layout for tactical operations, the Defiant bridge was significantly smaller than most other ships of the era, and was directly connected to the rest of deck 1 via two egress doors. The captain’s chair sat on a raised platform near the center of the room, giving the CO a commanding view of the entire room, with the helm located directly in front of it. The perimeter stations were, working clockwise from the viewscreen: science, tactical I, tactical II, and engineering. The back of the bridge featured a retractable situation table for mission briefings, above which was the dedication plaque.

    For several additional renders, please visit my portfolio.

    This model was originally created for OTOY and The Roddenberry Archive, you can fully explore this room at https://roddenberry.x.io/2371-uss-defiant-nx-74205/?view=Bridge.

    Software used:

    3D Modeling and rendering: Blender 4.5

    LCARS panels and textures: Inkscape 1.4

    OS: Ubuntu 24.04

    thumbnail
  • 24 Aug 2024

    Additional uniforms from 2373-2378.

    I will be doing my own versions of Starfleet uniforms in chronological order all the way up to the early 25th century. This project is not intended to be for a fanfic. Just doing this for fun. This is my take on the First Contact/ Deep Space Nine/Voyager uniforms, but with some changes for my timeline.

    I changed the dress uniforms to another design, as I never cared for the white uniforms introduced in Star Trek: Insurrection.

    Updated on 8/26/24 to correct minor mistake on cadet uniform.

    Based on a template by Grand-Lobster-King-www.deviantart.com/grand-lobst…

    thumbnail
  • 14 Aug 2025


    thumbnail
Jörg Hillebrand @ Mastodon
  • 07 Apr 2026

    Kivas Fajo's precious Mark Off-Zel vase in 's "The Most Toys"↖️ is later often seen again in Kkingon contexts' "Reunion"↗️, "The Mind's Eye"⬅️, "Redemption I"➡️, it even appears in Worf's possession in his Enterprise-D quarters in "Rightful Heir"↙️ and "Parallels"↘️.

  • 07 Apr 2026

    ' "Is There in Truth no Beauty?"⬅️⬆️⬇️ and "Day of the Dove"➡️ (both in the Enterprise rec room) feature three more alien planet surface paintings by Mike Minor. I particularly love the top one featuring an alien ziggurat (on Alpha ???) and a large crescent moon in the background.

  • 07 Apr 2026

    The filming equipment that was still visible at the top of the screen in this bridge shot in the original version of 's "The Mind's Eye"⬆️ was digitally removed for the remastered HD version of the episode ⬇️.

  • 07 Apr 2026

    According to a Christie's auction listing of a large Bajoran wall emblem, "The circle is based on a set drawing by set designer Nathan Crowley for a temple in "Emissary". The circular area with the spiral would have been a spiral staircase. The set design was not used, but it caught the eye of graphic designer Mike Okuda, who used it as the basis of the Bajoran symbol." The much simpler stair spiral that was ultimately used can be seen in the screenshot. 2/2

  • 07 Apr 2026

    The Bajoran map in 's "The Storyteller" is interesting as it does not contain the full Bajoran emblem but just the circular spiral part of the emblem, seen in all four corners of the map. In the future, this spiral will sometimes appear on its own, apart from the rest of the logo. 🧵 1/2

  • 07 Apr 2026

    Some of the Klingon objects (silver shields, huge vases, tables) seen in Vagh's office in 's "The Mind's Eye"⬅️ were previously seen in K'mpec's office in "Sins of the Father"➡️.

  • 06 Apr 2026

    Good-night!

  • 06 Apr 2026

    On , Klingon interiors usually feature some recurring architecural elements, like these light wall columns in "Sins of the Father"↖️ (horizontal only here), "A Matter of Honor"↗️, "The Icarus Factor"↙️ and "The Mind's Eye"↘️.

  • 06 Apr 2026

    Various stylized versions of the Bajoran emblem are seen as windows and door windows in 's "The Storyteller". It's interesting how both versions leave out certain and different elements of the design but are still instantly recognizable as "the Bajoran logo".

  • 06 Apr 2026

    Time for "Star Trek: The Motion Picture" - The Director's Cut in 4K. 👌👌

EAS Timeline @ Facebook
  • 07 Apr 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: Religious Strife - The next SID Rebirth story by Travis Anderson: Religious Strife. SID Rebirth: Religious Strife - a story by Travis Anderson
  • 07 Apr 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: Religious Strife - The next SID Rebirth story by Travis Anderson: Religious Strife. SID Rebirth: Religious Strife - a story by Travis Anderson
  • 05 Apr 2026
    Updated Reviews of VOY: "Repentance" and "Prophecy" - Two more Voyager retro reviews, of the thought-provoking morality tale "Repentance" and the hollow myth farce "Prophecy". Star Trek Voyager (VOY) season 7 episode guide and reviews
  • 05 Apr 2026
    Updated Links - I have updated the Links as well, though I had to remove more than I could add. Links to the best Star Trek websites
  • 05 Apr 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: The Orb - Here is another SID Rebirth story by Travis Anderson: The Orb. SID Rebirth: The Orb - a story by Travis Anderson
  • 04 Apr 2026
    Updated Reviews of VOY: "Shattered" and "Lineage" - Continuing with my Voyager retro reviews. Here are "Shattered" and "Lineage". I have revised my views on both episodes, and in opposite directions. Star Trek Voyager (VOY) season 7 episode guide and reviews
  • 03 Apr 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: Civil Unrest - Here is the next SID Rebirth story by Travis Anderson: Civil Unrest. SID Rebirth: Civil Unrest - a story by Travis Anderson
  • 03 Apr 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: Civil Unrest - Here is the next SID Rebirth story by Travis Anderson: Civil Unrest.
  • 30 Mar 2026
    New Article: Picard's Ready Room Crystal - Three items can always be found on Picard's ready room desk on the Enterprise-D: a black desktop monitor, a rack of orange isolinear circuits and finally a crystal. Jörg found out much more about the latter than we would have expected. See his all-new article Picard's Ready Room Crystal. Surprising observations about the crystal on Captain Picard's desk
  • 29 Mar 2026
    New Story by Travis Anderson: Syndicate - Continuing with the SID Rebirth series by Travis Anderson. Here is the next story: Syndicate SID Rebirth: Syndicate - a story by Travis Anderson
  • 23 Mar 2026
    Starfleet Academy Canceled - My Comment - Starfleet Academy has been canceled after only two seasons. Read Kurtzman's and Noga's message and my comment on this latest situation. The latest news and comments on ongoing Star Trek productions
  • 22 Mar 2026
    Updated: Observations in TNG: "The Host" - There are several additions and improvements in Jörg's article on Observations in TNG: "The Host". Observations about sets, props, make-ups and visual effects in TNG: "The Host"
  • 19 Mar 2026
    Update: Discoverse Future Alien Ship Classes - And here are the new Discoverse Future Alien Ship Classes: Torothan, Venari Ral and, of course, Klingon. Listing of alien starships that appeared in Star Trek Discovery's and Starfleet Academy's 32nd century
  • 14 Mar 2026
    Update: Discoverse Future Federation Ship Classes - I have added the designs from Starfleet Academy season 1 to the Discoverse Future Federation Ship Classes. I don't expect it to be quite complete, so please let me know what I missed! Listing of Federation starships that appeared in Star Trek Discovery's and Starfleet Academy's 32nd century
  • 12 Mar 2026
    Review of SFA: "Rubincon" - My review of the Starfleet Academy season finale "Rubincon" is up now. One interesting aspect is what doesn't happen. Beyond that, the path to the resolution feels predictable and plot-driven, though there are enjoyable character moments. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews
  • 09 Mar 2026
    New Gallery: Starfleet Academy Characters - Here is a gallery of Starfleet Academy Characters. Gallery of regular and guest characters from Star Trek: Starfleet Academy
  • 07 Mar 2026
    Speculation time! As awfully unrealistic the mine belt around the whole Federation is, it is another piece of a possible puzzle that may be more about family matters than about the usual "villain wants to destroy the Federation" narrative. Anyway, here are some thoughts about what may be revealed in episode 10: with spoilers up to episode 9 and predictions that may come true so don't read on if you love the surprise Ake is Anisha's mother and Caleb's grandmother In "Kids These Days", Ake seemed to be just a random Starfleet officer whose duty was to judge random criminals. If, however, she had an agenda from the beginning, if Caleb and Anisha were her relatives, it could explain why she was so devastated and quite her job after Caleb ran away. But it would undercut her role as the benevolent leader of Starfleet Academy and as Caleb's chosen surrogate mother - especially as someone who lost her son. And it doesn't look at all in "Kids These Days" like Ake knew anyone on the opposite side. Rating: 4/10 Ake is Caleb's mother, and he is unrelated to Anisha In addition to everything stated about the the idea of being his grandma, if she were his real mother, the bond between him and Anisha would lose significance, essentially devaluing what drove Caleb in the whole first season and his reunion with Anisha in "300th Night". Rating: 2/10 Anisha is the secret leader of the Venari Ral This theory is popular and has dramatic reasons to support it. Caleb could have his "Odo moment" in episode 10, maybe in a cliffhanger, learning that his mother is the leader of the evil people he has been fighting at the side of his new friends. He may have to choose between his mum and them. There is no evidence for this but also no evidence against it. Anisha may have just played a role on Ukeck, with the intention to carefully introduce her son into the world of crime. She may be the mastermind behind the Omega-47 minefield, with Nus Braka being just a henchman - one that is about to face her revenge because he didn't tell her he ran into her son - even twice. She was surprised to hear from Caleb that he met Nus. Actually, with Anisha being even more dangerous, Ake may have to ask Nus Braka for help yet again, now that Anisha is going after him and he is her enemy's enemy. On the other hand, would such an Anisha be fearful, or be able to fake that sense of fear so convincingly in "300th Night"? Rating: 7/10 Anisha developed the mines or was involved in other criminal acts of the Venari Ral Maybe she is not the mastermind, but she could be some kind of scientist working for Nus Braka, knowingly or unknowingly. She may have fallen out of favor with him, perhaps after tricking Nus during their prison break, which would explain why she is so nervous to be observed or ambushed on Ukeck. In any case, she could have a much worse criminal record than revealed so far. Ake may have been aware all the time that Anisha is not the nice troubled woman who made one mistake. The fact that Anisha spent a lot longer in prison than expected (and not in a penal colony), and even with Nus Braka, who was sentenced to life, insinuates she did a lot more than steal food and support Nus on that one occasion. This revelation would give rise to a conflict between Caleb and his mum, as well as between Caleb and Ake and possibly between Anisha and Braka as well. Also, as she designed them, she may know a weakness of the mine network that helps bring it down. Rating: 9/10 Braka is related to Caleb in some fashion Braka is obsessed with the boy. He may not be merely a random criminal with whom his mother hangs around. But does that make sense? He tried to kill Caleb twice, or at least, took his death into consideration. Could Caleb have undiscovered Klingarite DNA? Rating: 2/10 There is more to Ake and Braka than the trial Everything between Braka and Ake is deeply personal. It looks like more than a criminal who hunts the judge that once sentenced him. On the other hand, nothing in their various conversations points at there being more - which they would have revealed at some point, especially in "Come, Let's Away" when they were alone. Rating: 3/10
  • 05 Mar 2026
    Review of SFA: "300th Night" - Starfleet Academy delivers its so far clearly best episode with "300th Night". The season finale is only one week away, and I think there's hope for the series again. Star Trek: Starfleet Academy season 1 episode guide and reviews

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery