EAS Today

EditorialEAS CommentsEAS @ TwitterEAS UpdatesEAS @ DeviantartEAS Random Page & ImageJörg Hillebrand @ MastodonEAS @ Facebook

 

The latest posts and comments on this site and on the social media pages of EAS. See Trek Feeds for feeds from other important sites.

Editorial
19 Jan 2025

Why Starfleet Academy Deserves a Chance

The fandom appears more divided over Starfleet Academy than ever before. Many reject the series altogether, criticizing the setting, characters, storytelling and the inevitable "wokeness". The number of naysayers seems even greater than those who opposed Discovery. Either that, or they have simply become more vocal and visible. On the other side, supporters celebrate Starfleet Academy as a fresh opportunity to explore new worlds and seek out new audiences. That's only fair, but some dismiss criticism outright. I also don't think that framing disappointed fans as being of one mind with evil Elon is helpful. In the media, the middle ground is drowned out by the extremes. The episodes themselves almost feel designed to provoke division by alienating long-time fans with broad humor and heavy-handed references. Yet even detractors admit the show looks better than expected. The lingering question is: Can Starfleet Academy become a sustainable Trek series, one that simply requires time for audiences to adjust to its style?

I don't consider myself a detractor, but rather a skeptic. However, it is difficult to escape the framing, and in my case, to set aside grievances in order to enjoy what SFA does well. My reviews of "Kids These Days" and "Beta Test" seem to lean heavily on weaknesses, but as an afterthought, I want to highlight the strengths. The sets are spectacular. Everything is bright, crisp and polished, much like in the Golden Age of the 1990s. Despite occasional lens flares and CGI excess, the cinematography is outstanding. SFA is the best-looking modern Trek show. The cast also impresses. Holly Hunter delivers as expected, but the young actors deserve praise for making the cadets feel alive and likable. Then there's the broader setting. Discovery laid the groundwork, but its constant galaxy-saving missions left little room to explore the 32nd century in depth. SFA already does far more in terms of worldbuilding.

I believe Starfleet Academy has the potential to evolve into a meaningful series in the best Trek tradition, if it can deliver compelling stories while cutting back on the silly jokes, awkward situations and nostalgia overload. That said, one more aspect currently doesn't quite work for me. With the exception of Caleb, every cadet is an alien, yet they all feel essentially human. They are distinguished by special abilities, rather than by different values and traditions. SAM has even been programmed as a 17-year-old awkward human girl. I would expect cultural clashes, but the aliens integrate more seamlessly than a German exchange student at an American college. Ironically Caleb is the outsider in terms of the cultural background.

I try to keep an open mind and resist the polarized framing that surrounds Starfleet Academy. Still, my reviews will probably remain in flux as my perspective is evolving. What I can say with confidence, however, is that the claims of SFA being a "disaster" or a "disgrace" are totally exaggerated. The show certainly has its flaws, but I can only encourage fellow skeptics to give Starfleet Academy a fair chance.

Bernd Schneider

Archive

Latest Comments on EAS Articles (Overview)
  • 08 Jun 2026
    Here are the next two updated Enterprise reviews: "Fight or Flight" and "Strange New World".
  • 07 Jun 2026
    After completing the updates of my Voyager reviews, I am now revisiting Enterprise. All of these reviews were written when the episodes first aired, and over the past 25 years my views on many of them may have changed. So let us start with the pilot episode, "Broken Bow".
  • 05 Jun 2026
    Some Star Trek TV series fill the entire screen, some are letterboxed, and the classic ones need pillarboxing. A new article investigates The Evolution of Screen Ratios in Star Trek, summarizes the formats, points out oddities and discusses the technical and artistic reasons.
  • 31 May 2026
    For decades, Star Trek productions have relied on physical matte paintings, many of which have become iconic. A new article shows Notable Matte Paintings in Classic Star Trek and how they were used and re-used on screen. It places special focus on the contributions of Albert Whitlock, Syd Dutton and Robert Stromberg, artists whose original pieces appeared in Heritage Auctions between 2019 and 2021. Tell me in the comments which is your favorite!
  • 27 May 2026
    Less than two months to go. Everything is ready at EAS for recaps and reviews of Strange New Worlds season 4, which will begin with "Valles Marineris" on July 23.
  • 23 May 2026
    I originally just wanted to to untangle the investigations related to uniforms and inisgnias. But I went the whole way and created three practically new articles. The Changing Styles of Starfleet Uniforms keeps track of the many changes and the resulting problems. Starfleet Uniform and Rank Issues looks at mismatched insignias, odd uniform choices and bloopers like missing rank pips. The Starfleet Delta Symbol (this is the most extensive one in many years!) is about the evolution of the insignia and whether it used to represent only the Enterprise or the whole fleet. Bear with me, the last article is far from complete.
  • 14 May 2026
    I've added a lightweight image modal to all static EAS pages. You can now browse images in a clean overlay and navigate with mouse clicks, keyboard arrows or swipe gestures. And if you like things the old-fashioned way, CTRL-click still opens the plain URL in a new tab. It's intentional that the modal loads with a short delay, so it doesn't work when you click immediately after the page appears. As always - please don't hesitate to report problems to me.
  • 10 May 2026
    I conclude my Voyager reviews with the playful but somewhat shallow "Renaissance Man" and the ambitious series finale "Endgame", which works better for me today than it did 25 years ago.
  • 09 May 2026
    Two more old articles upgraded: Observations in TNG: "The Bonding" and Observations in TNG: "Booby Trap".
  • 03 May 2026
    I have added more references and better pictures to Jörg's article with Observations in TNG: "In Theory".
  • 01 May 2026
    Approaching the series finale. Here are the retro reviews of VOY: "Natural Law" and "Homestead" - one a fairly routine episode but with an interesting Prime Directive variation, the other a fitting and emotional farewell to Neelix despite some doubts.
  • 28 Apr 2026
    Two more old articles have been updated with new references and better pictures: Observations in TNG: "The Survivors" and Observations in TNG: "Who Watches the Watchers".
  • 26 Apr 2026
    Strange New Worlds returns with season 4 on July 23, and a new teaser trailer has been released. I have added a brief comment.
  • 25 Apr 2026
    New Voyager retro reviews are up: "Author, Author" and "Friendship One". The Doctor comes off as vain and insensitive, and the story still reframes him as the victim, while the second episode wastes a strong premise on a routine hostage plot and avoids its own key questions.
  • 19 Apr 2026
    I'm pleased to announce that TNG-Picard.com is a recipient of the EAE Award: a remarkable archive that shows a vast collection of screen-used costumes, props and models from TNG and Picard, built on a lifelong passion.
  • 17 Apr 2026
    Two more Voyager retro reviews: "Human Error" and "Q2". Recycled ideas and unrewarding outcomes hold both episodes back, from Seven's stalled development to Q Junior's predictable character test.
EAS Favourites @ Deviantart
  • 17 Apr 2026

    Model by

    CaptainWhitmire

    thumbnail
  • 14 Apr 2026

    The tiny Starfleet Blackbird-class scout is a mere 104-meters long and dwarfed even by starships from 100-years ago. Far smaller than famous cruisers like the refit-Constitution-class USS Enterprise, these 22-man vessels scout ahead of Starfleet task groups, conduct months-long sector patrols from local Starfleet Starbases and Federation planets, and conduct anti-piracy patrols along Federation shipping lanes, responding to distress calls from any Federation craft, and performing search & rescue missions throughout the Federation to fill in the gaps left by larger and more capable Starfleet ships.

    The Blackbird-class was created by Bernd Schneider in 1996 and is featured on Ex-Astris Scientia (https://www.ex-astris-scientia.org/my_ships/blackbird.htm)

    Exterior views by Bernd Schneider, updated by myself. Cross-sectional views and Deck plans by me.

    thumbnail
  • 13 Apr 2026

    The comet had no name yet, only a string of catalog numbers arrayed on the Astrometric LCARS. But to Lt. Alexa Wolff it felt personal, almost whimsical too. A point of light threading the dark, illuminating their way.

    She leaned forward towards the console, taking all the readings in. Data points left and right, immaculate scans of the surface and ejecta. This was exactly what she imagined as a child beneath the domes of Tycho City. Peering through her first telescope, reading stories of daring captains. Batel, Kirk, Saavik, the golden years. Now she was here, at the very same forefront.

    “Helm, bring us two hundred kilometers closer.” came Captain Han Lo’s voice over the comm. The visual lenses adjusted, Alexa noticing the Rooivalk was moving in closer, thrusters gliding her on. The hull catching faint reflections of the comet’s glow. The captain had not questioned her request, not even hesitated. The confidence in her expertise had startled her more than any formal commendation. Somewhere in the back of her mind, a younger version of herself smiling gleefully.

    Enhanced scans blossomed with new detail. Ice and dust resolved into layers. Ancient volatiles trapped since the dawn of time, now shedding themselves in delicate arcs. Alexa adjusted the filters, isolating elements, mapping a 3d simulation, simulcast to the bridge. “It’s beautiful.” she whispered to herself. Obscure beauty indeed. The kind that required patience, curiosity and faith that meaning existed in the far corners of space.

    “Careful, Lieutenant...” Captain Lo said, with a trace of amusement. “At this distance, we might inspire it. Give it a few million years and it could start its own civilization, studying us in return.”

    Alexa laughed softly, though her eyes never left the display. “Then we’d better make a good impression, sir.” She paused, recording another data stream. “If they ever ask how it all began, I hope it starts like this. With someone choosing to come a little closer.”

    ---

    3ds Max / Photoshop

    Vesper Class from ST: Online

    My Links: https://linktr.ee/jetfreak

    ---

    thumbnail
  • 12 Apr 2026

    The Kumari Battlecruiser (2)

    thumbnail
Jörg Hillebrand @ Mastodon
  • 08 Jun 2026

    Here's a comparison of the Klingon Great Hall in 's "Sins of the Father"⬅️ and "Redemption I"➡️. In the former episode, this was a large set with both a back and front side. In "Redemption I", only one (larger and wider) half of the set was built and then redecorated both as the front ⬆️ and back ⬇️.

  • 08 Jun 2026

    's "Armageddon Game" is another one of those episodes that does not have much to offer in the line of new Bajoran emblems, so here we see Major Kira and her Bajoran combadge again, from the front and (a little) from the side.

  • 08 Jun 2026

    Here's a shot of Qo'noS and its primary in the original ⬆️ and remastered ⬇️ versions of 's "Redemption I". This is only seen way in the background, explaining the fuzziness/blurryness in both shots.

  • 07 Jun 2026

    Here's a comparison of the Klingon Vor'cha class attach cruiser firing a torpedo in the original ⬅️ and remastered ➡️ versions of 's "Redemption I". I love the blue/green torpedo effect!

  • 07 Jun 2026

    There are no new appearances of the Bajoran emblem in 's "The Alternate", so I'm just posting these screenshots of Bajoran scientists Mora Pol and Weld Ram (not members of the military, I think), wearing the Bajoran combadge.

  • 07 Jun 2026

    Here's the same footage of the USS Enterprise-D approaching a planet/star in two different season 4 episodes, remastered in HD by two different FX teams. The ship approaches Praxillus in "Half a Life"⬇️ and Qo'noS and its star in "Redemption I"⬆️.

  • 06 Jun 2026

    The model footage of a Bird-of-Prey being destroyed while another BoP flies through the explosion was originally created for 's "Yesterday's Enterprise"➡️ before it was re-used in "Redemption I"⬅️. It's cool how the same footage can be used in different ways! :-)

  • 06 Jun 2026

    We get a nice shot of the Promenade directory in 's "Rival". The Bajoran entry (including the Bajoran emblem) can be seen at the bottom right. It's on the bottom left on the opposite side of the directory. I'll cover a noticeable absence of the Bajoran emblem in the episode...later! :-)

  • 06 Jun 2026

    Here's a direct comparison of the Klingon emblem and writing seen on the viewscreen of the Klingon attack cruiser in the original ⬆️ and remastered ⬇️ versions of 's "Redemption I". You can see how the emblem has been straightened up and the font is ever so slightly different.

  • 05 Jun 2026

    The Captain's chair on Gowron's Klingon attack cruiser in 's "Redemption I"⬆️ appeared earlier in season 4 on the Cardassian bridge in "The Wounded"↙️ and on the holodeck in "The Nth Degree"↘️. As can be seen, it was slightly modified each time.

EAS Timeline @ Facebook

Important notice Part of the above feeds, videos and galleries are not under the control of the EAS webmaster. EAS is neither responsible for the correctness and legality, nor for the safety and correct display of the external content. In order to preserve the visitors' privacy, EAS does not include any kind of "social plug-ins" anywhere, the only exception being the above gallery and video players.

 

TopShare
View as gallery